Saturday, January 15, 2005

First Post & Introduction

Hi, this blog is where I talk about religion from my secular standpoint. I'm somewhat friendly towards certain kinds of paganism (polytheism, ancestor worship), as well as to nontheistic Buddhism, but not so sympathetic towards the monotheistic religions. I was taught at school that the shift from polytheism to monotheism was a step forward in intellectual sophistication and in civilization more generally. Now, I think it was the opposite. Monotheism, with its totalitarian, anti-intellectual tendencies, destroyed most of the great achievements of ancient Greco-Roman civilization, suppressed learning, and issued in the Dark Ages. The Christianization of Rome was to that Empire what Mao's Cultural Revolution was to China, only worse, and longer lasting in its destructive effects.

Useful relevant link: Kenneth Humphreys has compiled Putting the Dark into the Dark Age, an excellent summary of how Christianity put European civilization back for many centuries, and is likely to be rather shocking, if you're unfamiliar with the information it contains. It gives a good picture of the narrowminded nature of monotheism.

1 Comments:

Blogger Rebecca Necker said...

Thanks for your comments, subconscious. You ask me to name a polytheistic religion that has "lasted long enough", well, I shall name two: Hinduism and Shintoism. Hinduism is the oldest-living documented religion in the world, with the Rig Veda, its oldest surviving scripture, being 3,500 years old. Shintoism has as its claim to fame a priestly royal house (that of the Emperor of Japan) that is the longest-surviving royal dynasty in the world (around 1,700 years).

You say that polytheistic religions only succeed if they involve a hierarchy with a boss. That may or may not be true, but a plurality of Gods is a plurality of Gods, regardless of whether or not there's a hierarchy involved. Zeus was king, but his supremacy was not absolute. His grandmother, Gaia, was alive, and she was pretty important, and his brother Hades was king of the underworld while Zeus ruled heaven.

You are right to say that the Islamic world deserves credit for scientific achievements during the Dark Ages of Christendom, but it is worth remembering that those achievements were built on work by polytheistic classical Greeks, as well as Hindus from India.

4:20 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home